Last updated: 17 February, 2012

EU’s Ashton “cautious and optimistic” about Iran talks

US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and EU foreign policy chief Catherine Ashton on Friday voiced cautious optimism about the prospect for Iran to return to nuclear talks with six world powers.

During a press conference in Washington with Ashton, Clinton called a letter that the European Union’s top diplomat had received from Iran “an important step” after a year-long hiatus in negotiations and sharp tension.

“There is a potential possibility that Iran may be ready to start talks. We’ll continue to discuss and make sure that what we’re looking at is substantive,” Ashton said at a press conference with Clinton.

“But I’m cautious and optimistic at the same time for this,” she added as US officials have suggested that the economic bite of sanctions may be pressing Iran to return to the negotiating table.

In a February 14 letter to Ashton, Iran’s chief nuclear negotiator Saeed Jalili said Tehran is ready to resume stalled nuclear talks at the “earliest” opportunity as long as the six powers respect its right to peaceful atomic energy.

Ashton represents the permanent five UN Security Council members — the United States, Russia, China, France and Britain — plus Germany in talks with Iran.

Ashton had written in her letter to Jalili in October that a solution was possible only if the talks focused on addressing Western concerns over the nature of Iran’s nuclear program.

Clinton, while stressing the six powers needed more time to study the brief letter, noted some positive signs.

“I think it’s fair to say… that we think that this is an important step and we welcome the letter,” the chief US diplomat said.

“As outlined in Cathy’s October letter to Iran, any conversation with Iran has to begin with a discussion of its nuclear program and Iran’s response to Cathy’s letter does appear to acknowledge and accept that,” Clinton said.

Jalili wrote that Iran welcomed a statement in the letter “respecting Islamic Republic of Iran’s right to the peaceful use of nuclear energy consistent with the NPT (nuclear non-proliferation treaty).”

“No doubt that by committing to this approach, our talks for cooperation based on step by step principles and reciprocity on Iran’s nuclear issue could be commenced,” Jalili wrote.

Ashton acknowledged that the letter contained “no preconditions and a recognition of what we’ll be talking about.”

Clinton also said “we must be assured, that if we make a decision to go forward, we see a sustained effort by Iran to come to the table to work until we have reached an outcome” whereby Iran complies with its obligations.

Clinton spokeswoman Victoria Nuland cautioned against any more “false starts” in negotiations with the Iranians.

“We’ve had negotiations that started and fizzled, or negotiations that ate up a lot of time and didn’t go where they needed to go to reassure the international community,” Nuland told reporters.

The last round of talks collapsed in Turkey in January 2011.

“The next question, really, is to look at then where we left off in Istanbul,” Ashton said, recalling that the powers had outlined confidence-building steps such as ensuring freer movement for inspectors.

The United States and other Western powers suspect that Iran is seeking to build a nuclear bomb, but Tehran denies the charge, insisting its atomic program is for purely peaceful purposes.

In a dual-track strategy, the six powers have offered Iran economic and diplomatic incentives to engage in negotiations to stop uranium enrichment work or pushed for imposing biting sanctions when they refuse.